Happy
Friday everyone! Last weekend the latest
John Green book to movie adaptation came out, Paper Towns. I had not read the book but wanted to do so
before seeing the movie. I finished the
book the day before I saw the movie so to say it was fresh in my mind when I
watched the movie version is an understatement.
That being said I decided to do a joint review. I'll talk about my thoughts and feels on the
book first then move onto the movie.
Book Rating: 4 Stars
I
should say that Paper Towns is my second John Green book, I read The Fault in
Our Stars before that movie as well. I
didn't snot cry like I did in that one so I call that a win. This was practically a happy book in
comparison. The book is about Quentin
'Q' who lives next door to the adventurous Margo Roth Spiegelman and had a
crush on her since childhood from afar.
Until one night when she comes to his window and him to accompany her on
an ingenious plot of revenge and adventure.
He joins in and for the first time he breaks his pattern and some rules
and comes alive and feels promise for the next day. That is until he arrives at school the next
day and Margo isn't there. Or the next
day or the one after that. She has
disappeared again the enigma she has always been. This time her clues seem left for him and he
believes he is meant to find her.
I
really liked Q. He was pretty great. His relationship with his best friends Ben
and Radar was just spot on and much fun.
The way they bicker back and forth and randomly just slack off on what
whatever tangent they were on always made me laugh. The friendship there was real and made me
want to be friends with them. Whereas
with Margo I didn't care for her much.
She was interesting in the beginning but after she takes off I cared for
her about as much as I did for Sloan in Since You've Been Gone. It started out slowly though and I grew to
like her less as the story went on but at the same time I was falling more in
love with Q and the others so it was a trade –off I was okay with. I just felt she was a bit self centered and
juvenile. I liked some of her ideas and
that she helped to break Q out of his shell and made him see life differently
for a change but that's about it.
Anywho
my dislike of Margo aside the story was rather good and compelling. I spent most of my life in North Florida
going to Orlando on a regular basis so to read about the place as just a normal
town and to have the characters visit places I've been to or could have been to
while I was there as a wee lass is fun.
The clues and the mystery was interesting and it took some thought to
leave them and to discover them. And I
mentioned it previously the way Q grows into himself really made the
story. It wasn't just a mystery to solve
but to see him step outside himself and deal with everything.
That's
all I can really say about the book without giving much away. Plus I really want to discuss the movie and
how they differ.
Movie Rating: 5 Stars
The
movie is for me rated higher than the book.
Strange I know. The book still
had many things that were better story wise but as a whole I feel I enjoyed the
movie a bit better because I didn't dislike Margo as much and I felt like I got
better answers. There will be spoilers
for the movie and book comparison below so just be warned.
Paper
Towns the book had more detail as any book does over their movie
counter-part. There was more clues more
adventures and such but they could drag a tad bit so cutting them and
streamlining was a smart call. I also
found out after they cut one due to the controversy surrounding Sea World and
not wanting to take part in it.
Okay. But one of the biggest
downsides for me was they cut the complexity of the search. Q wonders with all her messages and signs
that she might be waiting for him to save her or find her body. He is really unsure if she is leading him to
her or to her body. That was a deep part
of the search and the movie made it seem more like a boy with a crush going
after the girl he's loved from afar to 'get the girl' as it were. One other thing that does bother me in any
movie, there was a scene clearly cut from the movie that they filmed because it
was in the trailer which makes no sense but I hope to see it on the DVD.
Why
I enjoyed the movie better? I mentioned I
liked Margo better, she had more depth.
While I still found her somewhat self-centered her logic while flawed
did seem to make sense in a way. It
didn't seem as cruel. I also liked
changing the timeline of the story. The
gang racing to NY and trying to get back in time for prom was much more
believable than all of them ditching graduation. They kept the best parts of the book, the fun
and excitement but they also enhanced things like Ben's romance. In the book it just happened almost by
accident but in the movie it seemed more natural and progressed. I also LOVED the idea of including Angela in
the road trip. It kind of balanced
things out but also and more importantly it let us get to see more of her
character and by extension more of who Radar is. Also can I point out my theatre was having
some technically issues and I lost picture for a minute or two around the gas
station scene and just after. I did
manage to see the little cameo! But I
did miss the visual reaction to the T-shirt but I will be re-watching it again,
hopefully without issues.
Overall
I think fans of the book will enjoy the movie and people who have yet to read
the book will still be able to go in and enjoy the movie. The best of both worlds. So there are my thoughts and feels. Leave a comment below and share your thoughts
with me. Have you read the book and seen
the movie? What did you like/dislike
about them? Also I still have a giveaway
open until 8/2 at 12:00am EST for a signed copy of A Court of Thorns and Roses
by Sarah J Maas here so check it out. Until
next time!